Thursday, March 12, 2015

Copyright lawsuits brought against those accused of illegally downloading Manny Pacquiao documentary

LEVELAND, Ohio -- The producers of "Manny," a documentary about famed Filipino boxer Manny Pacquiao, have filed more than 150 lawsuits this month -- 15 of those in federal court in Ohio -- against those they believe downloaded the movie illegally.

The lawsuits, filed by Manny Film LLC, do not name actual defendants, but instead an Internet Protocol address attached to a computer. A person's actual name is added later in the case.

And experts say that the cases, while legitimate and strong, are part of a growing industry for some small-time movie studios that seek to obtain small settlements from those who are willing to quickly move past the situation.

The suits say the owners of the movie -- which is narrated by Liam Neeson and includes interviews with Mark Wahlberg and Jimmy Kimmel, among others -- lost a "substantial" amount of money due to the movie being leaked online. The documentary was distributed on peer-to-peer sharing websites and programs such as BitTorrent prior to its Jan. 23 release date, according to the lawsuit.

In each suit, the company asks for damages -- which could be tens of thousands of dollars -- as well as for attorney's fees. The company also asks that the defendants delete the movie from their hard drives.

Lawsuits have been filed in Ohio, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Florida. Of the 15 filed in Ohio -- five of which were filed Wednesday -- seven were filed in federal court in Cleveland.

In an email, "Manny" producer Jay Bajaj said the lawsuits, "target the worst-of-the-worst infringers; people who not only stole our movie but who are also building virtual Blockbuster stores of stolen content on their computers.

"These suits are just and we will pursue justice through them," Bajaj said.

After a lawsuit is filed, the companies typically ask the judge to allow the attorneys to issue a subpoena to a defendant's Internet service company to obtain an actual name. Once that happens, the suit is delivered to the defendant, or the company reaches out to them in the hopes that the cases settle, experts say.

The lawsuits pertaining to "Manny" are just one example of mass litigation brought by small studios that say they need to recoup the money they would have made through movie ticket sales and home rentals.

A 2014 study done by Matthew Sag, a law professor at Loyola University in Chicago, says copyright lawsuits brought against anonymous defendants by media companies are the most common form of copyright litigation in several parts of the country.

Mitch Stoltz, an attorney with the digital public interest group the Electronic Frontier Foundation in San Francisco, said a lot of these types of lawsuits are brought in the Midwest, likely because there are local attorneys willing to file them.

Guy Rub, an assistant law professor at Ohio State University, said these copyright suits are often strong. As a result, many defendants settle quickly because they do not want to deal with a protracted legal battle and run the risk of paying a large sum.

"Those are rarely litigated through and through," Rub said. "From the user perspective it's an extremely difficult case, almost impossible."

Still, Stoltz said it is hard to say how many cases were dropped and how many were settled. He also said it can be potentially problematic to file suit against an Internet Protocol address, since it is not always easy to tell how accurate a search is.

And while suing those who download copyrighted works is not new, the idea of it as a revenue stream is, Rub said.

He said larger media companies -- such as music labels -- stopped filing massive amounts of lawsuits several years ago because of bad publicity. However, the intended effects of those lawsuits was deterrence and not money.

With these smaller movie studios, he said, "I think the small guys actually want the money."

Source: http://www.cleveland.com/court-justice/index.ssf/2015/03/copyright_lawsuits_brought_aga.html

No comments:

Post a Comment